CCTV Timeline: What happened to Vhong Navarro

NBI lets CCTV footage from Deniece Cornejo's condo tell the story

This is the CCTV footage from the closed-circuit television cameras (CCTVs) of Forbeswood Heights Condominium in Bonifacio Global City in Taguig, where actor-host Vhong Navarro was mauled last week by a group of men led by businessman Cedric Lee.

The NBI weighs in

During a press conference on Wednesday, Jan. 29, the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) presented the footage taken from the CCTV cameras at the condominium's main gate, lobby, and elevator.

NBI assistant regional director Vicente de Guzman said, "Ang mga ebidensya po natin apart from the testimony of Vhong Navarro, is the video itself. Dito po nagtutugma yung testimony ni Mr. Vhong Navarro with that of what we saw in the CCTV."

Navarro has adamantly denied that he attempted to rape Deniece Cornejo inside her unit at the second floor of the building on the night of January 22.

The timeline

Citing the CCTV footage, the NBI presented a timeline of the night when Navarro was mauled inside Cornejo's condominium unit. They noted that the time stamp in the elevator's CCTV was 40 minutes (give or take a few seconds) late compared to the real time at the lobby's CCTV.

Based on the Forbeswood CCTV footage, Here is the chronology of what happened on the evening of JANUARY 22:

10:38 p.m. — Vhong Navarro enters the building's lobby.

10:39 p.m. — Vhong Navarro goes to the elevator and heads to the second floor of the building. (Note: The elevator CCTV's time stamp is 9:59 p.m. because, as the NBI had indicated, it was 40 minutes late compared to the real time at the lobby's CCTV.).

10:40 p.m. — Deniece Cornejo is seen riding the elevator going down to the first floor. She is then shown going out of the building entrance.

10:41 p.m. — A man identified as Cedric Lee enters the building. Lee then goes to the elevator and heads up to the second floor at 10:43 p.m. (Note: The elevator CCTV's time stamp is 10:03 p.m.)

At this point, the NBI emphasized that Cornejo had already left Navarro inside her unit, which means Lee could not have witnessed Navarro on top of her in her room as the businessman has alleged in several interviews. "I think it's not possible yung sinasabi nilang attempt to rape Ms. Cornejo... Kasi po very glaring dito sa ating footage na there was no incident na si Deniece was inside that room," de Guzman said.

10:43 p.m. — Two men—one of whom is wearing a white shirt and glasses and is identified as Ferdinand Guerrero—also enter the condo and go up to the second floor.

10:43 p.m. — Just seconds after the arrival of the two aforementioned men, Deniece Cornejo is seen going back to the building. She appears to be talking to a security guard, Bernice Lee and another man (who is yet to be identified) were also seen at the door. Bernice Lee is Cedric Lee's sister. Accompanied by the security guard, Deniece Cornejo, Bernice Lee, and another man then left the building again.

10:48 p.m. — A man whom Navarro identified only as "Mike" enters the condo. He also takes the elevator to the second floor.

10:56 p.m. — Bernice Lee is seen entering the building. However, she was not seen riding the elevator. The NBI said she might have used the stairs instead when she went up the second floor.

10:59 p.m. — Cedric Lee and Bernice Lee, who are on the second floor, head to the elevator and go down to the first floor. They leave the condo. (Note: The elevator CCTV's time stamp is 10:19 p.m.)

11:01 p.m. — Cedric Lee and Bernice Lee go back to the condo. Deniece Cornejo is with them.

11:02 p.m. — Cedric Lee, Bernice Lee, and Deniece Cornejo take the elevator and head to the second floor. (Note: The elevator CCTV's time stamp is 10:22 p.m.)

11:12 p.m. — A tied-up Vhong Navarro was seen entering the elevator. He seemed to be restrained by two men, who were both not seen in the elevator's earlier CCTV footage. (Note: The elevator CCTV's time stamp is 10:32 p.m.) One of the men was identified as bodybuilder Zimmer Rance. Others also followed them into the elevator: Cedric Lee, Bernice Lee, Deniece Cornejo, Ferdinand Guerrero, the guy known only as "Mike," and another still-unidentified man.

The NBI suspects that Zimmer Rance and the other man who was restraining Vhong Navarro were already in Deniece Cornejo's unit when the actor-host arrived. All in all, there are eight suspects in the case—a total of six men and two women.

11:13 p.m. — Vhong Navarro and the eight suspects were seen walking at the lobby towards the door.

11:14 p.m. — The CCTV at the condo's main gate shows the group leaving the Forbeswood premises.

It is presumed that the group split up and headed to different vehicles. Vhong Navarro, according to his own account, ended up in a van with some members of the group. He was taken the Southern Police District (SPD) where the suspects filed a blotter against Navarro for allegedly attempting to rape Deniece Cornejo.

Cases filed

Navarro, for his part, on Tuesday, Jan. 28 filed charges of serious physical injuries, grave threat, grave coercion, unlawful arrest, blackmail and serious illegal detention, which is a non-bailable offense, against Cedric Lee, Deniece Cornejo, and his other attackers.

Meanwhile, on Wednesday, Jan. 29, Cornejo filed a rape case against Navarro.

READ MORE:

Cedric Lee accuses Vhong of twisting facts

Ex-boyfriend defends Deniece Cornejo

Deniece Cornejo's message to Vhong Navarro

Jinggoy vows justice for 'best friend' Vhong Navarro

Full Transcript: Vhong's tell-all interview

ANC RECOMMENDS

  • Bonifacio High Street exhibit commemorates Christ's suffering

    Bonifacio High Street exhibit commemorates Christ's suffering

    Bonifacio High Street exhibit commemorates Christ's suffering

    Spirituality is at the core of Holy Week when the faithful commemorate the life, passion, and death of Jesus Christ. For five years now, 'Walkway' has drawn people from all walks of life to God, and each other. 'Walkway', which features a representation of the 14 Stations of the Cross, offers pilgrims and observers alike, a meaningful path to reflection. Church Simplified, the team behind the project managed to transform the busy street of Bonifacio High street to a ful blown art installation that is meant to bring you the passion and message of Christ. Bebo Bharwani, Spiritual Director of Church Simplified says they try to create serenity in an active environment, as art is a big factor for reaching out to non Christians. "Art has a way of surpassing critical art defenses. It iscrucial for expression, has a role in culture, and can be used to narrate the story." Organizers note, one of the people's favorite stations is Station 7, The Cross. There, visitors can actually lift a replica of the cross Jesus had to carry to give them a better idea of what He went through. Another favorite is station 9, where visitors are asked to write down a personal problem or worry on a piece of paper, and then nail the paper to the cross. Representatives from Church Simplified say, this part represents giving the pain to God, and leaving the problems in Gods' hands. "Walkway 2014: Reflections On the Stations Of The Cross" will run from today until Easter Sunday (April 19) along Bonifacio High Street.

  • House bill to require registration of airsoft guns

    House bill to require registration of airsoft guns

    House bill to require registration of airsoft guns

    Owners will need to register airsoft guns with the PNP

  • Skin Care 101: Amid the fun, be careful with the sun

    Skin Care 101: Amid the fun, be careful with the sun

    Skin Care 101: Amid the fun, be careful with the sun

    Summer is always the best time of year to be outside. But you must not forget that amid the fun, you must be careful with the sun. The skin is a very delicate organ that gets harsh exposure to the sun every day. Dermatologist Dr. Mary Jane Torres says her fundamental principle is to live a healthy life, as healthy skin always follows. Torres said you should eat the right food this summer, make sure you’re drinking at least 15 glasses of water, and never forget your sun block! Torres recommends SPF (Sun Protection Factor) 30 for a regular day to day basis. She also recommends using water based sun block or gel sun block to avoid the stickiness commonly found in thick creams. However, for a day on the beach, or at a sports event, Torres says you should go for a titanium dioxide cream or lotion. It acts a mask to protect you from getting burned by the harsh rays. Meantime, be sure to hydrate your skin regularly, and exfoliate to get rid of the dead skin cells. Make sure your skin enjoys summer as much as you!

  • Camarines Sur bus crash leaves 5 dead, 15 injured

    Camarines Sur bus crash leaves 5 dead, 15 injured

    Camarines Sur bus crash leaves 5 dead, 15 injured

    Among the fatalities was a 2-year-old boy.

  • MMDA to Holy Week motorists: Avoid EDSA

    MMDA to Holy Week motorists: Avoid EDSA

    MMDA to Holy Week motorists: Avoid EDSA

    A massive road reblocking project is set to begin in EDSA, which affects 94 segments going through Quezon City, Mandaluyong, and Makati.

MOST POPULAR ON ANC