The prize that is Fort Bonifacio


Makati and the Binays score, in a now 20-year battle with Taguig over Fort Bonifacio, with the Court of Appeals ruling, Fort Bonifacio belongs to Makati.

Ownership is in dispute because of transactions and laws dating back to the early 1900s. Makati and Taguig have been battling over Fort Bonifacio since 1993, when Taguig asked a regional trial court to declare the 729-hectare fort as part of its territory.

That was two years before the government privatized half the fort, leading to its transformation into one of the most expensive... and tax-rich... parts of the country.

In a July 15 ruling released today, the Court of Appeals said Fort Bonifacio belongs to Makati both on the merits, and because some of Taguig's evidence is inadmissible.

According to the ruling, "presidential proclamation nos. 2475 (Marcos) and 518 (Aquino) did not ‘alter’ boundaries but instead confirmed that said area is under the jurisdiction of Makati."

It added: “Parcel 4 is adjacent to Makati and Pasig (not Taguig). Hence, proximity-wise, Makati's claim is more credible than that of Taguig's."

Mayor Lani Cayetano said Taguig will fight the ruling, though she didn't say whether the city will ask the court to reconsider or appeal to the Supreme Court. "We will fight to make sure the disputed land remains with Taguig," she said. "We are confident we will ultimately win this fight."

Fort Bonifacio is a rich and still growing source of tax revenue, a rich prize not just for Makati or Taguig, but for the Binays and Cayetanos, the families that run them and may someday run against each other.

But other groups have a stake in this decision as well. If one government -- Makati --controls both the central business district and Fort Bonifacio, developers led by Ayala Land, and businesses lose some leverage. They will no longer be able to lobby Makati or Taguig to make things easier for them, or cut or cap taxes and fees, with the unspoken threat of moving to the other city.

And it may create a political or bureaucratic situation for the Taguig civic center where SM Aura is located. Because while courts may deem the donation of the land to the Taguig government as legal and valid despite BCDA objections, it would be a Taguig-owned property within Makati.

Like a foreign embassy. Or West Berlin.

Watch more business news here

ANC RECOMMENDS

  • 'Profs for Peace' call for peace, fact-based discussions on Mamasapano

    'Profs for Peace' call for peace, fact-based discussions on Mamasapano

    'Profs for Peace' call for peace, fact-based discussions on Mamasapano

    Members of the academe issued a statement on Tuesday, calling for peace and "fact-based" discussions on the Mamasapano incident. The group Professors for Peace said that they are alarmed by the hatred surfacing amid discussions on the clash that led to the death of 44 elite cops, 18 Moro rebels, and several civilians. Instead of hatred, the group said the citizens must learn more about the deeper context of the problems in Mindanao, and how one can contribute to the lasting peace in the country.

  • Alice Dixson talks Super Feed/Feel Detox Challenge

    Alice Dixson talks Super Feed/Feel Detox Challenge

    Alice Dixson talks Super Feed/Feel Detox Challenge

    Many health advocates have taken to cleansing or detox as a staple to healthy living. For some of them, this means replacing diets with natural, nutrient-laden liquids. Others go beyond that, pairing their wellness challenge with zen moments by replacing toxic thoughts and feelings with positive vibes.

  • Modern Living TV Season 2

    Modern Living TV Season 2

    Modern Living TV Season 2

    For many of us, modern and innovative architecture, captivating interiors, and some of the country's most appealing real estate properties have been a staple for ANC weekend viewing. After a successful first season, Modern Living TV is back with an exciting new season filled with the best and the latest in the world of real estate, architecture and design.

  • Camarines Norte farmers increase pineapple-based products

    Camarines Norte farmers increase pineapple-based products

    Camarines Norte farmers increase pineapple-based products

    Pineapple farmers in Camarines Norte are finding new ways to earn with the help of pineapple fiber.

  • Butuan artist turns junk into works of art

    Butuan artist turns junk into works of art

    Butuan artist turns junk into works of art

    An artist from Butuan has found a way to turn junk into masterpieces.

MOST POPULAR ON ANC

  • Military conducts operation vs. BIFF
    Military conducts operation vs. BIFF

    Residents of Barangay Maitomaig in Datu Unsay town in Maguindanao have started to pack their things and flee their homes following after reports that armed men had blocked GenSan-Cotabato National Highway using tires which caused motorists to stop and go back.

  • PNoy fed 'lies' on Mamasapano operation?
    PNoy fed 'lies' on Mamasapano operation?

    President Benigno Aquino III reportedly told House leaders he was fed "lies" on the day of the Mamasapano, Maguindanao operation.

  • Deles: Not the time to demand surrender of MILF men
    Deles: Not the time to demand surrender of MILF men

    Two government officials said this is not yet the time to demand from the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) that they surrender their members who were involved in the deaths of the 44 police commandos.

  • 2 minority solons push for Enrile house arrest
    2 minority solons push for Enrile house arrest

    Two minority congressmen are seeking house arrest for detained Senator Juan Ponce Enrile.

  • AFP, PNP hold unity walk along EDSA
    AFP, PNP hold unity walk along EDSA

    Amid coup rumors and the controversy over the Mamasapano encounter, members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) and the Philippine National Police (PNP) held a unity walk along EDSA as part of the People Power celebration.

  • Crime alert: Scammers using 'Fallen 44'
    Crime alert: Scammers using 'Fallen 44'

    Authorities are now warning the public against a scam wherein the 44 fallen Philippine National Police-Special Action Force (PNP-SAF) are bring used to trick people into parting with their cash.

  • Peping Cojuangco cries overkill in EDSA Shrine barricade
    Peping Cojuangco cries overkill in EDSA Shrine barricade

    Former Tarlac Rep. Jose “Peping” Cojuangco slammed the barricade set up at the EDSA Shrine where groups were supposed to hold vigil later Sunday as part of protests against President Benigno Aquino III.

  • MILF asked to explain 'photos with Abu Sayyaf'
    MILF asked to explain 'photos with Abu Sayyaf'

    Some senators on Tuesday asked the government and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) officials to explain new photos allegedly showing MILF members training with the Abu Sayyaf in Panglima Estimo, Sulu.

  • SAF weapons returned by MILF either 'cannibalized' or defective?
    SAF weapons returned by MILF either 'cannibalized' or defective?

    After nearly a month since the January 25 Mamasapano encounter, the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) returned 16 firearms its fighters took from the fallen SAF troopers.

  • Binay wants house arrest for Enrile, Arroyo
    Binay wants house arrest for Enrile, Arroyo

    Vice President Jejomar Binay on Saturday described as ''cold and callous'' the government prosecutors' opposition to the house arrest of Senator Juan Ponce Enrile.